Mainstreaming of FriendFeed

I think FriendFeed is pretty cool, but I still don’t know why it’s a must have. So it aggregates a wide range of social networks and media to present a social feed… but why should you or anyone else care? What value is this creating in my life? But none of this is stopping the cheering section from declaring FriendFeed the winner in social network feeds before a market has been defined.

FriendFeed has been described by different folks as a social Web lifestream, by others a Web services aggregator, or as a conversational platform. But it’s not just one of these things – it’s all of these things. There are a definitely a wide number of sites out there that let you share all your activity in one place, or to track friends’ activity, but FriendFeed is the only one that lets you share items directly to the feed, elevate discussions through comments and show “likes” to highlight individual posts.

[From louisgray.com: Duncan Riley Misses the Point of FriendFeed: Silicon Valley Blog]

Adam Ostrow says that FriendFeed has crossed the chasm. No offense to Adam, but that statement is so patently absurd on it’s face that it rises to the level of being preposterous.

First and foremost, the only people that are connecting to me on FriendFeed are the same people that connected with me on Facebook last year and the same people who are on Twitter and the same people who connect to me on every shiny new toy I try out. FriendFeed can’t even see the bridge to cross the chasm, it certainly hasn’t crossed it yet.

Adam says that they are collecting gobs of data about what we do, but I say that doesn’t mean the data is commercially viable or even commercially accessible (witness Beacon). Just having data doesn’t mean shit, you are no closer to defining a service that can be delivered to an economic buyer than not having the data at all, in other words just having the data doesn’t mean you have the right data.

But in the end the biggest failing of FriendFeed is that it’s like standing in a very crowded room with everyone shouting at you, there’s no sense of proportionality or authority that helps define what I should be paying attention to.

I still think it’s pretty cool.