The UK is Insane

I read news from the UK and shake my head at how far off the rails that country has gone. Take this example of the latest nanny state initiative, equating using a cell phone while driving with driving while intoxicated. Actually, it’s considered worse than DUI because drinking and driving is not illegal, as in the U.S. it becomes illegal when your blood alcohol level exceeds a threshold, but under these new rules, any use of a cell phone while driving would be illegal.

[UPDATE to clarify, when I read this post I realized I made a mistake in presenting my logic. I said “is considered worse than DUI” but what I should have said is that is “worse than drinking and driving” because DUI is always a criminal offense. Drinking and driving is not criminal, the subset of people who drive after drinking enough to be legally intoxicated are breaking the law.]

I would challenge anyone to consider the facts first, while mobile phone usage has skyrocketed over the last decade, highway fatality statistics have been flat since 1986, well actually they rose slightly in 2006 but that was due to pedestrian and motorcycle fatalities increasing. While proponents of these laws will say any number above zero is unacceptable, it is unreasonable to believe that zero is actually achievable and elevating inherently non-dangerous behavior to criminal, as is the situation in the UK where cell phone use while driving is more prosecutable than drinking and driving, devalues the efforts to curtail behaviors that are dangerous and criminal.

It is a good suggestion, and in many cases the law, to use a handsfree device while driving and this is a reasonable public safety measure. I have a bluetooth setup in my car and couldn’t imagine not using it, not only does it free my hands to focus on driving, but it’s more convenient to use than a handset. To criminalize any cell phone use while driving is just insane.

Motorists caught using a hand-held mobile phone while driving could be jailed for two years under tough new guidelines issued today by prosecutors. [From Drivers who use mobile phones face jail – Telegraph]

4 thoughts on The UK is Insane

  1. Pingback Jackie Danicki » I guess it beats indifference
  2. To a certain extent it is symptomatic of a government floundering for something to arrest the slide it has seen in the last few months. The logic being some sort of “law & order” initiative always goes down well with the public. Until it starts biting the public.

  3. You think that’s nutty, they banned chasing foxes while on horseback a couple of years ago!

    But surely on drinking legislation the US would be tough to beat on dumb laws. So at 18 you can be drafted to go fight for your country but you can’t have a beer? What gives?

  4. As ever, there is a balance to be found. There are already laws capable of prosecuting people using a mobile phone in such a way as to be causing a menace (which many do). We used to call this driving without due care and attention. But if a silly law can be dreamt up, the UK Labour Government can do it.
    The latest advice in the Highway Code (Rules and advice for drivers) is to pull over if the sun is in your eyes. I predict this will become law, rather than advice, in the near future…

Comments are closed